Peer-Review

Initial Editorial Assessment

Scholarly articles presenting research findings, including research-based case studies and material studies, undergo peer review before publication.

The editorial team first assesses whether the manuscript falls within the journal's aims and scope, meets basic scholarly standards and complies with the author guidelines. Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be rejected without being sent for external peer review.

Peer Review Process

Each manuscript is subsequently evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. Reviewers are selected from institutions other than those with which the authors are affiliated and must have no conflicts of interest involving the authors or the work under review.

The journal operates a double-blind peer review process, in which reviewers do not know the identities of the authors and authors do not know the identities of the reviewers.

Reviewers assess the scholarly contribution, appropriateness of the methods, evidence supporting the conclusions, use of sources and clarity of presentation. Authors receive the reviewers' reports and, where revisions are requested, submit a revised manuscript together with a response to the reviewers' comments. Depending on the extent of the changes, the revised manuscript may be returned to the reviewers for further assessment. In the event of substantial disagreement between reviewers, the editorial team may seek an additional independent review.

Editorial Decisions and Conflicts of Interest

Decisions to accept, request revisions to or reject a manuscript are made by the editorial team on the basis of the reviewers' reports and the authors' responses, in consultation with the Editorial Board. The final decision on publication rests with the Editor-in-Chief.

Where an author is a member of the editorial team or Editorial Board, the published article will disclose their editorial role and explain how independent review was ensured. The author concerned does not participate in managing the peer review process or in the decision on acceptance.

Non-Peer-Reviewed Content

News, updates, book reviews and other informational contributions that do not present original research findings undergo editorial assessment. These contributions are clearly identified as non-peer-reviewed content.

Review and Publication Times

The time from manuscript submission to the first editorial decision following peer review is normally approximately three weeks. The time required for author revisions and any additional rounds of review depends on the extent of the changes requested. Publication normally takes place within approximately two months of final acceptance, depending on the journal's publication schedule. These timeframes are indicative. In the event of a significant delay, the editorial team will inform the corresponding author.

Complaints concerning the peer review process and appeals against editorial decisions are handled in accordance with the procedures described in the Publication Ethics section.

Downloads

Peer Review Report Form [INSERT LINK]